Kunjungan :
  Article
Energy Illiteracy


Thursday 14 Feb 2008 7:12pm
  What is Energy illiteracy?
This can be explained as follows: Imagine a person who is 3 meter tall (9feet) and has a bodyweight of 40kg (80pound); your mind will directly be able to visualize this person’s body shape……right? This means you are length and weight literate!

If I tell you that this morning I ate 5kJ (kiloJoule) of food for breakfast; for sure you will be puzzled about this information; you probably have no clue about if that amount is a lot or a little. The same when I tell you that my car is very energy efficient because it consumes only 5MJ (MegaJoule) per km. You will again probably have no clue if it is really efficient or instead extremely in-efficient. You are simply not able to determine if this energy amount is a lot or a little because we never talk about a car’s energy performance in Joules per km. The fact that most people have no clue about if a certain amount of energy is a lot or a little; can be called energy illiteracy.

Even the energy-people are energy illiterate because they never look outside their own industries. The oil-guys talk in barrels; the power-guys in watts, mega and GigaWatts, the coal-guys talk Metric Tons; the gas-guys talk in Cubic Feet or meter, Alternative-fuel –guys talk Mtoes, Solar-guys talk Wattpeaks, battery-guys talk Amp-hours, wind-guys talk watts although they should talk wind-watt-peaks to be fair to solar guys……..and the list goes on and on…..

No wonder that most people are energy illiterate; the right unit for energy is never used!

No wonder we are ending up in a huge worldwide energy-crisis while continuing to burn everything we can find and even specifically grow stuff for the purpose of burning it….energy illiterate energy experts are advising energy illiterate politicians who in turn try to tell the energy illiterate public what to do…..

It’s time to start addressing the energy illiteracy problem!

The first step towards eradicating Energy illiteracy is introducing a standard:
That should be obvious! The reason why people are length and weight literate is because we always measure those properties with the same standardized units; no matter if we measure a door or the length of a room or a table. So in order to eradicate energy illiteracy we have to start using a standard unit for all energy forms.

The most obvious unit for Energy is Joule for the following Reasons:
1) Joule is already standardized as the unit for energy in the metric system.
2) Joule is already widely used all over the world in electricity (you probably never heard of that because Joule always has gone under cover of Watt; The definition of Watt is Joule per second.) Most electric engineers do not know that because they only learn one definition that Watt = Current x Voltage...and thus even electric engineers are energy illiterate...

Watt cheats the energy conscious customer…..

If you were an energy conscious customer and had a choice between 2 refrigerators that look exactly the same but have a different wattage; which one would you choose if, let’s say fridge 1 has a 70 Watt compressor, and fridge 2 a 100 Watt compressor?

Most people will without second thought go for the 70Watt thinking that it consumes less energy.

That’s the way you get cheated; Watt gives you only information about how many Joules it consumes per second while most of the appliances in and around our house consume electricity the whole day with a continuously varying pattern. Information about a second is for sure not enough to determine if something is energy efficient or not.

What is more important to know is how many Joules per hour per day or per year are consumed.

Let’s assume the 70W fridge has a compressor that runs for 3,000 seconds per hour; this means that the fridge consumes 70 x 3000 x 24 = 5,040,000 Joules per day ( = 5 MJ per day). It could be possible that with a new more efficient compressor of 100W the compressor only runs for 1,000 seconds per hour; this means that the fridge will consumes 100 x 1000 x 24 = 2,400,000 Joules per day ( = 2.4 MJ per day).

You see the wattage does not say anything about how much energy is consumed; in above sample the 100W fridge consumed less than half of the 70Watt fridge. This means you can be badly cheated as an energy conscious customer when you focus on a low Wattage.

What should be mentioned on all energy consuming devices is how many kJ, MJ it consumes per hour, day or year or certain result. Lamps and TVs are used on hourly basis and thus should be labeled in MJ or kJ per hour. Fridges are used on daily or monthly basis and so should be labeled with how many MJ’s are consumed per day or Month.

In fact Watt should be eradicated altogether because it is misleading information; and it has no importance at all for the operation of a certain device.

What we really need to know is energy and current to determine if the electrical wiring can stand the current draw. Wattage is completely irrelevant.



(Maurice Adema)

 
 

 
   
There are 4 comments on this article
 
 
 
 

Comment 1 By: bedouin

Saturday 29 Mar 2008 4:12pm

Hi Maurice
I appreciate your candour and approach to this industry.
I fear this kind of candour is not the sort to be appreciated by the general industry and so, I suggest you do what you know even if you are alone in it for awhile.
I am assured that your customers and sincere associates will identify with you and your project - and the results will speak for itself...

Best of luck
Appreciative Reader/Singapore
 
 
 

Comment 2 By: Oly Serafica

Monday 31 Mar 2008 5:25pm

Energy Illiteracy may be a jolting and attention-getting heading but it would be too harsh to describe the problem as it may hit some sensitivities. Illiterate connotes uneducated or unschooled. While the advocacy appears well-intentioned and I personally support the sharp comments and drastic recommendations, tact and diplomacy should be exercised to solicit support.

Suggested heading: Harmonized Energy Standards.
 
 
 

Comment 3 By: Sarjono Alibazah

Wednesday 23 Apr 2008 5:10pm

Whatever the term used (whether Energy Illiteracy or Unharmonized Energy Standard or whatever), whether anyone appreciate it or not, the fact remains that a lot of people still believe that Watt is the unit measurement of Energy (do you?). It isn't.

There's no other way of saying it, but it just shows that people (including those in the industries) are still illiterate about energy. Very few seems to be able to see the interconnection between oil, electricity, sunlight, food, batteries, etc. (otherwise we'd all be taking in the common currency Joule already by now, instead of the plethora of barrels, MTOE, Gigawatts, or whatever other isolated units). Look at all those things from their energy value, and you'll see what the writer of this blog means. Perhaps sometime in the future I can pay your 100 MJ batteries with 100 MJ of my apples, because they are all equivalent tradeable energy!

BTW, if you browse the net, you'll find that "Energy Illiteracy" is already a common word, and not condescending at all. It just means not being able to "read" Energy... yet. Nothing to be shameful of (I admit I was energy illiterate too, and if it weren't for Maurice's writings I would still be... there I said it).
 
 
 

Comment 4 By: Bert kuilman

Thursday 22 Jan 2009 4:54pm

Make sure that the "(standard) MJ per day" for the fridges are based on the same test conditions. A fridge at 10 deg. C. will use less energy than one at 30 deg. C. even if they are exact the same.

But if all fridges are tested at 20 deg. C. it still can be more efficient to use the lesser one if you use it outside the test condition.

So be aware of your situation and don't fly blind on the MJ/day.

Fluorescent light will decrease efficiency at below freezing point.
Reverse for Led light, its efficiency will increase at cold temperatures.

If you use fluorescent lights to replace incandescent bulbs in an office you need to replace de incandescent bulbs heat (kJ) by the same amount of kJ for room heating. Room heating kJ are much cheaper than light kJ of course but the energy used will be the same.

So... what’s energy..? Your wallet..?
 
 
   

Add your comment

Comment 5

By:
  Email*:
* Required, but not published
   
Type the word displayed on the left

 
How did you hear about this site?
Search engines   Friends   News/blogs   Seminars  Books/magazines   Ads   Other
       

   

Add this blog to my Technorati Favorites